The US House Republicans have issued a blistering report on the country’s 2021 withdrawal from Afghanistan, assigning much of the blame to President Joe Biden’s administration. It is the result of years of investigation into one of the messiest pullouts in American history—one that involved tragic incidents, such as suicide attacks at the Kabul airport, where 170 Afghans and 13 US soldiers lost their lives.
Contents
Summary of the Report
The House feels that “the Biden administration made some grave mistakes in the implementation of the withdrawal. It not only caused the exit to be disorganized but also damaged the global credibility of the US.” But some of the toughest criticism comes out of a decision to stand firm by an August 31 pullout deadline, when the Taliban’s gains and military officers’ warnings that things were on the cusp of entering a catastrophic phase seemed to resonant around that date. It had said earlier or phased withdrawal would have confined chaos, perhaps making sure that Kabul did not fall.
The report further reveals how the administration lacks in contingency planning. The report reveals that the administration could not predict how fast the Taliban began to take over; it did not have an articulated, well-planned scheme to protect Afghan allies and citizens who in any way assisted US forces. This failure is quite evident from the chaotic scenes at Kabul’s airport as thousands of Afghans scrambled to flee at the last minute.
Republican Response on Republicans
The Republican leaders have said that accountability shall come from the report. “This report makes clear there needs to be a full accounting of what went wrong,” said House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy. The Republicans believe that the American people have the right now to know how the withdrawal could go so terribly.
Defense by Biden Administration
But the Biden administration has defended scenes unfolding in Afghanistan by arguing that it was merely fulfilling the agreement negotiated by former President Donald Trump. According to them, given the circumstances in play—particularly the sudden collapse of Afghanistan’s government and military—scenes were bound to happen. In fact, said White House spokesperson Karine Jean-Pierre, “The withdrawal was always going to be a difficult operation, and the administration worked hard to adapt to an evolving situation.”
Wider Considerations
The report added that the Afghanistan conflict impact will be long-stretching well beyond the immediate withdrawal and for years to come in US foreign policy and military strategy. The controversy has soared to the skies since the findings in the report as both Republicans and Democrats reformulate and use its messages in their respective advocacies—some from attacks against failures of the administration, while others have focused on defense based on previous negotiations of Trump with the Taliban.
And now that Congress continues to deliberate and analyze the report and investigate the events leading to this withdrawal, the Biden administration continues to face sustained tenterhook media scrutiny of their management of this significant foreign policy crisis.
Stay connected with fact and us for more such news.